Sunday, January 14, 2018

Strings Players and Dancers

Hi  all.

This will be a bit shorter and certainly less developed than some of my other ideas expressed in this blog.  It is more of an observation today.  Here is the  quick thought:


  • String players = start with technical,  work toward expressive.
  • Dancers = start with expressive and work toward the technical

My Recording Technology class recently completed an assignment that I call the Dance-Mix Editing assignment.  The students are tasked with editing several of their favorite songs together in mo more than 32 pulse segments, editing for consistent tempo, consistent or complimentary key and tonality, 8 count phrases, and "cutting to resolution."  The idea is that it could be used for a dance team or cheer-leading team routine with no difficulty.  I am always pleased to hear the resulting ideas and themes that emerge with this first project of the course.

As we were reviewing all of the projects in class, I came to find out that one of my students is particularly interested in dance and took a particular interest in this project the possible applications to his art moving forward.  A wonderful conversation about dance and movement ensued, spurring the following train of thought.

String playing and dance are certainly similar. Both require a great deal of physical training in order to become proficient.  Both require a great deal of kinesthetic rhythmic movement. And both, when done well, can elicit a great emotional response.  That said, it seems to me that string playing typically begins with a focus on the technical and can lead to emotional expression of ideas with perseverance and determination.  Conversely, dance and dancers typically begin with a desire to demonstrate emotion and eventually develop the techniques that  facilitate this pursuit.

A few months ago, I wrote a related post entitled What? and How? I that post, I explored the need for young artists to be aware of the areas of technique, artistry, purpose and perspective.

This may be a subtle difference, but I don't think so.  Having been around instrumental string music education for over 30 year, I have observed students and teachers alike.  I pay attention to string pedagogy and love to consider the intricacies of teaching.  Us string players are obsessed with technique.  I think that we all really want to be expressive, but I find that it is very difficult to attain artistry.  In fact, I have written before that is was very hard for me to consider my self an "artist" until well into my middle-age years.  I was a technician.

I have enjoyed watching various dance shows over the past several years, including So You Think You can Dance, Dancing with the Stars, and others.  One of the things that strikes me always is the artistry and artistic motivation of everyone from the judges, to the pros, to the students. The motivation of the dancer seems to begin with the artistic.  From there, the best dances seek out the technique that is needed to further their art.

Us string folks seem get there from the opposite direction.  Young students (or perhaps  sometimes their parents) want to learn how to play the violin.  They rent an instrument, go to their lessons, and begin the process of learning the techniques of playing.  If they hang in there long enough, they will make the transition to artistry.

I head about 150 violin students audition for a regional orchestra festival yesterday.  I will bet that I heard less than 10 get close to an idea of expression or artistry.  Don't get me wrong:  Artistry is hard. And, one MUST learn the proper techniques in order to demonstrate artistry.  So, I am not suggesting there is anything wrong with any of this.  I just find the dichotomy to be very interesting and telling.

By the way, I was just thinking about kids that start on the guitar and other "rock" instruments.  Many of them begin with an artistry motivation as well.  But, the techniques that are required for real expression with a guitar can be attained significantly quicker.  Tone quality for a power chord happens pretty fast. Tone quality on a violin is a lifelong pursuit.

What are your thoughts? I welcome your feedback and remarks.  Meanwhile, string players: seek out artistry.  You ARE expressive. You ARE artists.  Play with an ear toward moving your audience at all times!

Peace.
Scott


Thursday, January 4, 2018

Audition Thoughts


A few weeks ago a friend asked me if I would create a post with some thoughts about auditions. This season in public schools sees many auditions for district, regional, and all-state band and orchestra events. I have judged on audition screening committees for many years and have also sent hundreds, if not thousands, of students into auditions as part of their regular process in high school orchestra over the past 31 years. So, after a busy couple of weeks over the holidays, here are some of my tips and thoughts.


1. Always focus on accuracy.


Too many students get focused on learning a whole piece at tempo that includes hard passages. In other words, they look at the big picture too quickly.  In reality, it is the details that matter:  clear intonation, accurate rhythm, accurate style and technique, confident accurate fingering, appropriate bow technique.  Adjudicators are looking for clean, accurate performances in auditions. Show that you have done the foundational practice.


2. Never stop practicing slowly.


This is an extension of accuracy.  I recently spoke with a conductor from a major US symphony who told me that the top soloists in the world still review difficult passages slowly in their dressing rooms just prior to performances.  Students tend to get a passage learned and up to tempo and never slow down again.  Bad idea. Your brain has the opportunity to make all necessary neurological connections if you repeatedly practice fast passages slowly and methodically - even after you can play them fast.  A good plan for fast passages is the following: 4 times slow -  1 time fast, 3 slow - 1 fast, 2 slow- 1 fast, 1  slow- 1 fast.  Repeat.  Every day. This promotes accuracy and clear intonation.  I encourage students to do a very slow and careful run of difficult passages as their final bit of prep before going into the audition room.


3. Pay close attention to all markings in the written score and make the judge know that you have noticed them.


Judges are looking at a copy of the music.  I would estimate that on average 80% of auditionees ignore all or at least a large percentage of dynamic markings. It is your job to make the judge notice that you have noticed them! Of course there are other markings as well.  Look for martele' accents, staccato or legato markings, rallentando, stringendo, and others.   I encourage students to practice their piece with an eye toward EVERY written mark in the score at least once a day.  Emphasize wide dynamic swings and extremes.  Don't let the judge think that you didn't know the marked dynamic.


4. An audition that is a few clicks slower and accurate is better than a few clicks faster and sloppy.


As a judge, I would always prefer to hear an audition a bit slower and clean over fast and sloppy.  Again, I think that kids feel like they have to be at the tempo of a recording and feel like the tempo is the most important thing.  Obviously clean AND fast is best.  But, sloppy is never a good idea. and, sometimes just going a click slower can make you feel like you have extra time to think during the audition.


5. Tone quality matters.


Tone production should be an integral part of preparation for an audition.  This would include bow use and technique.  Focus on a beautiful sound in all phases of preparation. It sounds like a no brainer, but so often I hear students focus on passages and not on tone.  Also, new strings a week or so before the audition might be a good idea.  You would be surprised how many times I see/play student instruments with strings that are several years old.  A new set of strings can do wonders for student tone.  (By the way, don't change strings right before an audition - they may need a day or two to settle in.)  By the way, rosin your bow!   Tone is definitely impacted by rosin.  


6. Find the shape of every line.


Those of you that know me won't be surprised by this.  I want to hear direction of every line.  Where is the line going?  When does it arrive?  When does it depart?  The answers to these questions must be obvious to the judge. And, the student musician must have a vision for the direction of every line.  This is what breathes life into a passage. This is what shows up in the "musicianship" score.  


7. Judges are looking at your bow hold! (At least I am.)


Seems simple.  But, I will bet that 80% of the students that I hear/see in an upcoming regional orchestra audition room will have a flat right thumb.  It is that simple.  An appropriate bow hold impacts tone and technique at every level.  I can tell immediately if a student has a good bow hold.


8. In the audition, focus on your task at hand (your performance), not on the desired result.


Read the book "Choke," by Sian Beilock.  It gives lots of great justification for this.  If we let ourselves think of the desired result, (a high seat or getting into the group)  our brains are distracted.  Think of your brain as a CPU.  There is only so much capacity for information.  Use the capacity for the task at hand. Focus on the performance. Focus on all of the techniques that were solidified by your slow, thoughtful preparation.  The results will take care of themselves.


9. Don't neglect scales and sight-reading.


In North Carolina, scales and sight-reading are 50% of your score. So many students do well on the solo and give points away on something as rudimentary as scales.  Practice scales with a drone. Practice scales slowly, for true intonation.  don't just play scales for the "right" fingering.  Think tonal center at all times.  Practice sight-reading daily.  Have a routine: look for key, time signature, accidentals, shifts, time changes, etc.  Don't give away potential points on scales and sight reading.  https://practicesightreading.com/create.php  http://thesightreadingproject.com/


10. When preparing your scales, focus on accuracy, not just on fingering .


See above.  Practice scales with drones.  Practice slowly. Pay attention to tonal center.  Know them inside and out.  


11. Practice your audition in front of anyone who will listen as much as possible.


You will play better in an audition if you are comfortable in new performing situations.  So, practice new performing situations.  Play for friends, relatives, friends of relatives, relatives of friends.  Play for anyone who will listen.  Try to create situations in which you are a little nervous.  There is no substitute for experience.


12. Auditions are like photographs. Sometimes when we have our picture taken we look better than we should and other times we look worse than we should. Pictures (auditions) rarely provide an exact picture of your development. Think about it: in order to get one good set of 5 or 6 senior pictures, there might be 100 actual photos taken.  We don't get a perfect photo every time and we don't get a perfect audition result every time. There are so many factors that come into play.  Is it early or late in the audition day?  Were there hundreds of auditions that day?  Did you have a big lunch? Did you hear a really good audition right before you?  A really bad one?  The list goes on and on.  I have seen so many students over react to a seating or placement as a result of a 3 minute audition over the years.  Play the audition. Do your best.  Let the judges create a seating or result and if you are disappointed, get over it fast.  Use it as motivation for sure.  But, don't let it ruin your day.   It  is rare that a seating in an orchestra is an exact representation of the quality of musicianship from chair 1 to chair  20.  It gives a general idea of the picture you took on that day at that time for that judge.   Period.  Don't ever let a single audition be a litmus for your long term work and preparation.


So, these are my ideas today based on my years of experience.  I hope you find it helpful. Please share this with your students and colleagues.  And, most importantly, all you students: Good luck on your upcoming auditions.  I hope this helps you to be just a little more prepared as you walk into that audition room.  And, for those of you that want more perspective on performance and auditions, I really recommend that you reach Choke.    It is a good read with lots of application to the audition and performance process.


Peace.

Scott

Wednesday, December 13, 2017

"Those who can..."

I grew up in a family of educators. My Dad was a teacher, Principal, and eventually Superintendent of Schools in my hometown. My Mom was a well-respected English teacher in a neighboring school district. The home I grew up in encouraged me and my two sisters to be academically curious and engaged in our school work on a daily basis. We were expected to get good grades. We were encouraged to learn how to play musical instruments. We were encouraged to participate in leadership activities. We were encouraged to join school clubs and student government. We were active in our church. There were high expectations in our home and each of us succeeded in our classes and in our activities.  We were also expected to be of the highest character and we took it seriously.  So did most of my friends.

When it was time to select a college major, I considered many different avenues. I had a feeling that music would be a good choice, but I wasn't sure what I should do.  In the end, it was clear to me that my parents felt that it would be a noble choice to choose education. They knew the life of a teacher and encouraged me to follow that path. They made sure that I knew that teaching was not a life oriented towards getting rich or owning a large home. It was a life built on scholarship, service to others, character, and true engagement in a community. While I wasn't sure that I wanted to be a teacher, education seemed like a smart initial choice for a college major.  It also offered the most clear path to an actual job following graduation for me.

While in college, I succeeded again. I was a top musician at my university, graduated Summa Cum Laude, and did my best to be a leader in the music community and broader community at my university. I still remember the day my professor told me, "You don't know it yet, Scott, but you are a teacher." I student-taught with distinction and graduated with a strong knowledge base, a high level of musicianship, and a real passion for teaching that was a result of contact with mentors who truly cared for me and helped me find my path. I left college ready to impact some community with my talents,  knowledge, and passion for music and string education.

It wasn't long after I graduated that I first heard the phrase: "those who can't do, teach." That phrase caught me completely off-guard. I couldn't believe it. I had spent my entire life going to school, enjoying school, and really investing my heart and soul into the process of learning. I respected my teachers. Yes, I even loved my teachers. My parents, whom I respected at every level, had invested their passion and intellect in public school education. Suddenly I was finding out that people disrespected the teaching profession. Truly, it caught me completely off-guard. 

As I continued pursuing the teaching career I couldn't have been more impressed with my colleagues I was around people every day who loved their jobs, loved their students and work, and completely committed to scholarship at the highest level. This has been the case nearly every day since I started teaching over 30 years ago.  My experience has been that the vast majority of teachers are very similar to me: committed, ethical, intellectually curious, and caring.

Of course everyone has some experience with "that teacher." The teacher who doesn't work so hard and isn't as committed to the highest levels of scholarship as all of the other teachers. But, that person is the exception to the rule. The vast majority of teachers that I have encountered over the years are true academics,  hard workers, and unbelievably committed to working for students and excellence at every level.

I recently opened my Facebook to read a scathing article about the incompetence of young people today and ultimately misguided teachers and public education.  The article asserted that young people are coming out of public schools with low knowledge and high sensitivity.  The article asserted that students from private schools and wealthy homes may be an exception, but that public education is producing a society of misinformed, low character, college graduates.  I read it as a complete attack on public education and teachers in general.  I can't believe that group of people who work so hard for the public good would be the brunt of this kind of misinformation. So, please hear me.  The vast majority of public school teachers I have encountered in my 30 year career are exceptional scholars. They are folks that are selflessly committed to the public good. They are people who are academically curious and of the highest character. They are people who love their students. They love their subjects. And they honor and respect people of all colors, races, sexualities, genders and backgrounds.

Now I know that you can find almost anything on social media nowadays.  Folks have all sorts of agendas and political leanings.  And, I certainly can't give that one article too much of my time and attention.  It is certainly representative of one groups misguided opinion.  As for me, I am proud to have chosen teaching as my profession and passion.  And I am pleased that teaching has chosen me. For all you teachers out there, these kids need us.  They need our  scholarship, our guidance, our care, and our encouragement.  Keep fighting the good fight. And remember: those who can, teach!




Fluency and Music

Music performance, at its best, must be fluent.  Listeners expect to hear uninterrupted lines that include clear communicative information.  Listeners desire accuracy and true competency from performers. From the simplest tunes to the most virtuosic concerti, the test of a fine performance is demonstrated fluency.

In recent weeks, I have been using a model/metaphor of fluency and music a great deal in my classes. Many of you know that my early music training is Suzuki violin instruction and the fluency model seems natural to me as a result of that instruction. I would like to take a little bit of time today to outline some of these thoughts.

Fluency is the ability to read a text accurately, quickly, and with expression. Fluency provides a bridge between word recognition and comprehension. When fluent readers read silently, they recognize words automatically. They group words quickly to help them gain meaning from what they read. Fluent readers read aloud effortlessly and with expression. Their reading sounds natural, as if they are speaking. Readers who have not yet developed fluency read slowly, word by word. Their oral reading is choppy. Fluent readers demonstrate accuracy, expression, pace punctuation, and comprehension.

So, in music it is very similar. Fluency in music would be explained as the ability to read and perform a score accurately, quickly and with expression. I often tell my students that there is a difference between  "comprehension level" music learning and "performance level" music learning. A fluent musician would demonstrate accuracy, expression, pace, punctuation, phrasing and comprehension within the context of the performance.

I am using the fluency model particularly frequently in my Classical Piano and Guitar course at the North Carolina School of Science and Math. This is a course designed for all levels of instruction. I teach beginning piano and guitar as part of the class and also work with more intermediate or advanced students who have some or extensive experience on their instrument. Many of these students come to me with a blank slate of experience and others come with varying levels of competency in music and music reading. In order to get all students moving in a similar fashion, I ask them all to consider their work in music using the fluency model.

The model is as follows:
Everybody learns to speak by learning individual words. As we learn a word we use it over and over. A great example would be the word "hot." A small child learns the word "hot" and then uses it in repetition until it becomes an active part of their vocabulary. The same is true for the repertoire my students are learning. They learn a musical concept, technique, or song, repeat that technique or song many times and it eventually becomes part of their active musical vocabulary.

We can also add the act of music reading into this model. Initially, small children read one letter at a time, then one word at a time, and eventually read full phrases and sentences with ease. The same is true for music. We can tell when students are reading isolated individual notes, then phrases, and eventually entire pieces.

For my beginning students, I explain to them that by learning repertoire and maintaining that repertoire, they are developing a vocabulary.  They must continuously use that vocabulary of musical techniques to become fluent. Thus, if a student continues to play a basic song over and over, the song eventually becomes fluent and flowing. The student can play the piece much like we speak, without overly thinking the individual aspects of the piece. Thus, they are operating in a fluency model.
My beginning piano and guitar students typically learn between 10 and 15 songs in a trimester. By the end of one term, they are fluent in each of those pieces and have a repertoire or "vocabulary" to build on.

Often times it is more difficult to convince my more intermediate students of this concept. So many students with some experience come to me thinking that they are much more fluent than they actually can demonstrate. Fluency involves a true understanding of all aspects of the vocabulary. In other words, one must know how to identify individual letters of words, define each word in a sentence, put the sentence together, and say and read it with inflection. That requires a great deal of skill! It is the same with music. The fluent musician must understand each individual note, its rhythm, its place in the musical phrase, how to read and perform that phrase accurately, and how to inflect that phrase accurately and fluently. So many students have spent all of their time working on simply notes and rhythms or just imitating their teacher or recordings. It is rare for students to arrive in my class fully fluent in every aspect of the repertoire they are used to learning. This sometimes causes problems because I want them to be able to demonstrate fluency in all aspects of their performance. Many of them have to revert to simpler repertoire to actually achieve this goal.

I find that the fluency model is also effective in my orchestra rehearsals. Early in the rehearsal cycle, we are reading. We are sounding out "words," finding connections and cues in the written score, and operating on a more remedial, functional level. As the students begin to learn a work more extensively, they can perform more fluently. The work is less about the minutiae and more about the larger ideas. Some students never get past the point of the remedial reading phase. Others get to the fluency phase much earlier.

One strong difference between an ensemble performance and my piano and guitar class is the fact that everybody needs to be fluent for the orchestra to perform with fluency. Even a small number of players that haven't achieved that fluent level can bring the ensemble performance down.  Right now, my orchestra is preparing for a performance of a Mozart Symphony and it is so imperative that every player is fluent in their part.  Even small inconsistencies can yield negative results.

I also find the fluency model to be applicable to the world of improvisation.  When we are speaking extemporaneously, we are effectively "improvising" with words.  In other words, we are calling on phrases and ideas that we have learned and prepared ahead of time that fit into the context of the conversation at hand.  This is improvisation at its best.  In order to improvise, we call on our experience with and preparation in concepts surrounding key, mode, rhythm, time, melody, and expression (to name only a few). 

Additionally, fluency in conversation requires listening.   So, this model provides a great vehicle for discussing the importance of listening in solo and ensemble music performance. In order to respond appropriately to a phrase or idea, one must be willing to listen to the information that precedes.  

I recently had a wonderful conversation on this topic with a student who is bilingual. English is his second language.  He learned English as a teenager and did so by putting labels with the names of objects all over house.  He had labels on the table, chair, desk, book, shirt, etc.   He told me that now he sees labels in his mind all the time.  And, in fact, now both languages require thought. For him, music does not have any labels.  It never did.  So, now music is his most fluent language.

In closing, I asked my students to articulate their understanding of fluency as it relates to both language and music.  One said, "Fluency is getting past small picture to big picture.  Another shared, "Fluency is not having to think specifically about the technical. It is simply expression."  Finally, a third remarked, "Fluency is like liquid: free and expressive."

I encourage to give this model a try with your students.  It has really resonated with my students and I feel like they have a more accurate picture of the true goals of rehearsal and performance.

I wish you all and your students many fluent performances!

Peace.
Scott

Tuesday, October 17, 2017

Nanigo, Thom Sharp

This is a video of a recent performance.  It is me soloing with the NCSSM Orchestra for the kickoff of the NCSSM Alumni weekend.  The piece is Nanigo, by Thom Sharp.  My part is improvised.  It is a good example of my idea of functional musicianship where I add another part to an existing string orchestra arrangement.  Enjoy!!

Scott



Monday, October 16, 2017

Tuesday, September 12, 2017

Ensemble Musician's Taxonomy of Musical Mental Habits

Over the past several years, I have noticed that student musicians can fall into a static mental mode while in various stages of the rehearsal process.  If they have mastered their individual part (notes and rhythms) they simply check out mentally and wait for the next basic challenge. I have a number of theories as to why this happens. But, for now I will stay away from my theories about why and simply discuss the issues as I see them and possible solutions.

Let me describe the problem that I see. I find that students are interested in playing correctly. I also find that they are used to being told specifically what to do in rehearsal. What I find missing, are appropriate habits of mind or habits of what to be thinking about throughout the rehearsal process. For instance, if a student has mastered the notes and rhythms of a particular passage and the conductor continues to review that passage, my feeling is that students don't understand what they can be thinking about individually while the repetition is occurring. So, with that in mind, I felt it would be important to discuss this concept with my Orchestra. As we began to develop a list of things to think about while in rehearsal, it became apparent to me that there is a hierarchy of these concepts  that one might consider while in rehearsal. Obviously, early in the rehearsal process, basic ideas such as right notes, right rhythms, key signature, time signature, etc. are the things that one should focus on. However, as the rehearsal process progresses, each individual should be able to move on to higher order skills in the ensemble rehearsal process.

For instance, after a student has mastered the notes and rhythms, they may then move their thought process to the written dynamic scheme of the piece. Or, they may be compelled to think about bow direction and or bow placement. Or, they may to turn their attention to other parts in the orchestra, focusing on what's happening outside their own part both around and with them. This, to me, begins to look like a taxonomy. That is, a sort of hierarchy of priorities and mental habits within the ensemble rehearsal process.

Here is the list that we came up with in class.  I have been keeping it posted on the white board at the front of the room. Then, if a students needs some ideas on what to think about, they can refer to it quickly.  
  • Accurate Rhythm and Time
Obviously, these are the first steps in learning a piece of music.  Right notes played out of time are wrong notes.  So, I place a great deal of emphasis on rhythm early in the rehearsal process.
  • Accurate Notes and Key 
Very close behind rhythm is tonal center and correct notes.  Obviously.  The thing is that many teachers never get past this spot in the taxonomy.  This is understandable.  If the students are out of tune, this must be corrected.
  • Playing Technique
I try to give all of my students individual technique goals. These can be left or right hand position, bow hold, set up, right had fluidity, vibrato, etc.  Then, they can focus on this when they have learned the basics of their part.
  • Written Dynamics
This is the next obvious step in preparing a part.  It is written on the page, for goodness sake.  I encourage my students not to  think about dynamics as some fixed value, but rather to consider them in the context of the overall piece.
  • Fingering/Shifting
This is one of the first big shifts in thinking that I find I can affect.  So many kids think that they only need to shift when the part gets high.  I try to change that way of thinking to looking at fingering from a perspective of ease of passage, tone color, and string crossing.
  • Bow Direction and Use
In a perfect world,  this would be higher in the taxonomy.  I feel like this is incorporated into every moment of every rehearsal.  I don't usually over-bow string parts for my orchestra.  I want them to be thinking critically about direction as it pertains to style, dynamics, and articulation.  Bow direction is so subjective.  I usually have very clear priorities, but I love to articulate them in the context of a great discussion about bow direction.
  • Articulation
This is strongly related to bow direction.  I find that students often come to me with a very limited palette of articulation options.  I try to get them thinking about the initiation of sound throughout the rehearsal process.
  • Vibrato/Tone Production
Vibrato  and tone production are often the difference between an average overall sound and a mature sound.  But, where do changes occur and how can these be varied?  These are important questions for each musician to be constantly asking themselves.
  • Artistry/Direction of line
This is where real musicianship develops and emerges.  When we can get a student to think about this independently, they are truly on the way.
  • Tempo/ Push-Pull
This is typically dictated by the conductor, but the students that are intuitive with this can help the group along!
  • Section and Individual Balance
Where do I fit in the dynamic balance of the orchestra? Where does my section fit in the dynamic balance of the orchestra?
  • Section and Individual Role
What is my role in this passage?  What is my section's role in this passage?  Melody? Harmony? Off Melody? Bass line?  Engine?  Rhythmic Underpinning?  Sustain/Pads?  Teacher? Student?  What else?
  • Perspective and Emotion/ Performance
How might I move during this passage?  Who should I look at?  What is the overarching emotion of the passage?  


So, what have I missed?
Is this something that you may be able to use with your classes?

I  truly believe there is something here for everyone.  We have all had that precocious kid that thinks their work is done before they have even scratched the surface.  Maybe this can work for them.  Or, maybe your whole group would be open to thinking about this.  I certainly hope there is something here that you can use in your ensemble.  

Peace.
Scott